☎+86-577-86826961

sales@eaglefittings.com

What Does Sanitary Mean In Connections?

What Does Sanitary Mean In Connections?

The term sanitary does not mean clean for the average person, and thus the confusion. Sanitary connections do NOT mean sanitary connections that have been cleaned, but instead are those that CAN be cleaned and be documented that they are cleaned without having to take apart and rebuild each time the cleanliness is being evaluated. The way we identify sanitary fittings and make those distinctions is based solely on geometry and documentation and NOT based on what it looks like or how it is finished.

Quick answer: in piping, "sanitary" means to be able to clean the piping in place (during use) and have no dead areas in the piping for product to build up or collect. Sanitary connections are intended to be used for sanitary applications (regulatory and hygienically) and NOT for the purpose of cosmetics. For example, a mirror polished fitting with a threaded joint as part of the product path is not sanitary. Whereas, a bead blasted fitting with a clamp joint and the appropriate radius may be a sanitary fitting.

The following information will detail what sanitary connections are, how they differ from standard connections, the different types of fittings included, the various materials used to manufacture, and where costs related to sanitary fittings and connections come from.

What "sanitary" means in engineering terms

Sanitary, as defined by the standards, refers to the cleaning process of a given assembly to a specified level and by a specified method. The cleaning method usually consists of caustic and acid washes that are performed without having to take apart the assembly.

The cleaning process must meet three criteria at the same time: The material used must be resistant to chemical attacks from both the product and the cleaning solutions; the material's geometry must allow the cleaning solution to flow over all surfaces at a fast enough velocity; and the joints must be flush with each other, so that none of the product gets trapped in the joint where the cleaning solution cannot reach.

If any one of these conditions is not met, the assembly cannot be classified as sanitary regardless of how well the other two conditions are met. For example, if a sanitary assembly is made of 316L material but has a threaded tee connection, the assembly cannot be classified as sanitary. Conversely, if an assembly has perfect geometry but the fitting is made of 304 material and is being used in a chloride service environment, the assembly will not be sanitary for long. This is why the sanitary classification applies to the entire assembly instead of just individual pieces.

How a sanitary connection differs from an ordinary one

In comparison, an ordinary connection joins two pipes together with enough force to hold pressure. A sanitary connection uses the same strength as an ordinary connection, but has added benefit of allowing the joint to be easily cleaned and inspected. The key differences between the two connection types are as follows:

First, the way the seal is made. With a sanitary clamp joint, the seal is made with an elastomeric gasket placed between two ferrules, at the same time as being compressed by the use of a clamp. This gasket is flush with the bore of the fitting. Since there is no thread in the pathway of the product, it cannot become contaminated from the thread or the space between two parts of a joint. On the other hand, an ordinary connection has a threaded area in the product path, and bacteria can take up residence in the root area of the threads, which cannot be cleaned by means of a cleaning solution.

Second, the inside surface finish. The inside surfaces of sanitary tubing and fittings must have a polished finish (the Ra ≤ 0.8 µm for food contact and ≤ 0.38 µm for pharmaceutical work) specified when ordering these products. Ordinary pipe will be ordered by the size and material opened by a mill, and the inside finish of the product will be whatever was left from the previous processing steps at the mill.

Third, definition of complete drainage. The design of a sanitary pipeline must allow for complete drainage under gravity. To accomplish this, the pipeline must not include horizontal lines that do not have fall or slope, but only represent slope without dead legs or drainage points. A dead leg will be defined as a branch that ends without any flow and should have a length no longer than a few diameters of pipe.

Fourth, documentation. A sanitary item will have documentation: a material certificate, a surface finish report, and (for regulated grades) a 3-A or EHEDG certificate. An ordinary item will have a delivery note when it arrives.

Sanitary fittings are considered sanitary if they have a clamp or orbital weld rather than thread, welded, or flanged joints; have no common product-contact thread; feature a surface finish of Ra ≤ 0.8 µm (often Ra ≤ 0.38 µm); have no dead legs (i.e., areas on the fitting that don't drain all the way down) and that they drain completely; and that there is documentation showing that the fittings meet the requirements of the mill certificate, along with documentation outlining the material, surface finish, and 3-A/EHEDG certification.

Property Ordinary industrial Sanitary
Joint threaded, welded, flanged clamp, or orbital weld
Product-contact thread common not permitted
Internal finish mill finish Ra ≤ 0.8 µm, often ≤ 0.38 µm
Dead legs acceptable designed out
Drainability not specified required
Documentation mill certificate material + finish + 3-A/EHEDG

Material: why 316L and not 304

316L is preferred over 304 for sanitary piping because 316L piping contains molybdenum, which helps prevent pitting corrosion when exposed to chlorides. Molybdenum helps to protect against pitting attack due to chlorides from two primary sources: the dairy product itself (which contains 0.1% chloride) and from any cleaning cycles (which is often chlorinated).

As time goes by, a 304 surface will develop pitting due to being immersed in these environments. Pitting is a crevice that will not drain, making it difficult to clean and becoming a hygiene issue, in addition to being a mechanical failure.

The "L" in 316L is also significant because low-carbon 316L steel does not precipitate carbides at the welded joints, which creates a chromium-depleted zone at the weld area. This is where the majority of sanitary piping joints occur. As such, the material specifications for sanitary tubing are written as 316L and not "316," and putting a 316 fitting to a 316L line is an actual defect rather than a paperwork problem. The tube standard laying out the dimensional and finish specifications is explained in the ASTM A270 guide to sanitary tubing.

The second material variable is surface finish. Mechanical polishing leaves a directional finish with visible lines; electropolishing removes the outer layer of material and results in a smoother surface, with increased corrosion resistance, and a brighter surface. Mechanical polishing to Ra 0.8 µm is adequate for the majority of food applications, while electropolished surfaces with a Ra of 0.38 µm are standard for pharmaceutical and biotechnology fields, and the price differences between these two types of finishing can be vast.

Geometry: dead legs, radii and drainability

Geometry requirements exist because cleaning fluids must come into contact with every part of the equipment; as a result, any place within a piece of equipment where cleaning fluids don't reach is considered a dead leg. Sanitary fittings should therefore be constructed using long-radius bends as opposed to short elbows, and tees with smooth transitions rather than square branches.

Dead legs are perhaps the most frequent defect encountered in real-life situations. A tee installed for the purpose of being used for a sensor that was subsequently removed will create a blind leg where product may pool between cleaning cycles. Contamination will develop at the closed end of the blind branch and will contaminate the line when the blind leg is disturbed. The maximum allowable length of a dead leg in hygienic design is between two and six pipe diameters long, as measured from the inlet outlet wall to the outlet end of the dead leg.

One of the most common mistakes regarding drainibility is making a line that has been drawn down, straight and level. You can install the line straight and it will typically create a low point in the line where product accumulates. Even if the fitting you are using for the line has been manufactured to specifications, unless you allow for drainage, it is likely to not pass inspection.

The Internal Radius has to do with the radius at every transition within a sanitary fitting and must be large enough for the cleaning fluid to flow over the fitting and not through it. The Internal Radius is a manufacturing detail and does not necessarily show up in specification numbers; therefore, the Internal Radius of a sanitary fitting is one of the distinguishing characteristics between a quality sanitary fitting versus an average sanitary fitting. A general overview of Parts with regards to Internal Radius is shown in the Overview of Common Sanitary Pipe Fittings.

The connection types, and where each is used

There are four primary Connection Systems for Sanitary Work, and they should not be used without Adapter Parts.

Tri-Clamp or Clamp Connections are typically used with Food and/or Beverage applications. They allow for very quick break-apart capabilities, can be easily inspected, and are able to be assembled/disassembled without tools. Three-A defines the dimensional standard for North America; common sizes range from 1" through 12".

The SMS connection is the equivalent of the Tri-Clamp in Europe; it uses a different ferrule profile, which has a rounded nut, and is widely used in Northern European dairy applications. DIN connections use a third profile, and RJT uses a fourth profile predominantly in the UK. None of these connection types mate directly with the Tri-Clamp connection type; therefore, any project that uses different suppliers without verifying the dimensioning standards will require the purchase of adapters for each connection point.

Where a permanent joint is acceptable, and cleaning can be accomplished by circulating cleaning solutions without needing to dismantle any equipment, welded connections are used. Orbital welding produces a clean and smooth joint without crevices, and the weld joints are inspected via Borescope. Welded connections are the standard for pharmaceutical process applications and all components that form connections on food processing lines that will never be opened.

The choice between clamp and weld is essentially reliant on the desired frequency of maintenance. Clamp joints have the ability to open for inspection and can be replaced within minutes; welded joints are permanent, but they do not have the associated long-term concerns of deteriorating gaskets. Lines that are cleaned in place and have minimal maintenance (daily stripping) will be welded, while lines that are stripped each day will utilize clamping connections. Both types of joints are constructed with sanitary materials; however, their respective failure modes differ.

Selecting a valve to use with a given application follows the same rationale whether the application is handling product or cleaning fluid; therefore, the dimensions set forth for the ferrules to make the clamp interchangeable with a non-clamp fitting are defined within the sanitary fitting measuring methods.

Which fittings count as sanitary fittings

Sanitary fittings comprise an entire collection of items within the product flow, from the discharge / tank outlet of a Bulk Delivery Truck (BDT) to the filling system.

There are four core sanitary fittings: the tube, the clamp ferrule, the gasket, and the bend/tee. Sanitary fittings also include valves (butterfly, ball, diaphragm, check), sight glasses, spray balls, manways, and instrument tees. All of these fittings have a sanitary version and an industrial version. The differences between these two types of fittings are the same for all fittings; no product-contact threads, a specified surface finish, and a geometric design that permits drainage and cleaning.

Gaskets should receive special attention, as they are the most commonly replaced items; a sanitary gasket is moulded to match the ferrule profile, and is constructed from a material that is approved for food contact (i.e. EPDM, silicone, PTFE, FKM depending on temperature and chemicals). Flat sheet gaskets should not be used as sanitary gaskets; they extend into the bore, create a crevice at their edge, and are among the first items inspected by an inspector.

An inventory of all sanitary fittings, even those that are frequently forgotten, can be found in the reference to sanitary fittings, listed by function, not catalogue order.

Standards: 3-A, EHEDG and ASME BPE

3-A Sanitary Standards, EHEDG Standards and ASME BPE are the three primary standards in the sanitary industry. Furthermore, there are differences in the development of these standards.

3-A Sanitary Standards are American and were established by the dairy and food industries, with assistance from the manufacturers of equipment. A 3-A certificate indicates that the design of a specific type of equipment has received a thorough review of the manufacturer's cleanability criteria against certain criteria established by 3-A, whereas the number on a fitting signifies that the fitting is compliant with the cleanability criteria established for that particular number. For example, 3-A 63-03 applies to fittings, whereas any other certification number would not cover that specific fitting being provided.

EHEDG provides an equivalent to the 3-A certification in Europe. Instead of using a prescriptive dimensional standard approach like 3-A, EHEDG uses guidelines combined with a certification process to establish compliance for hygienic designs of equipment components or products, allowing for greater flexibility, but making it more difficult to verify at a glance.

The ASME BPE standard is the most prescriptive of these three, with ASME BPE providing the most technical specifications for the finishes and welds associated with pharmaceutical manufacturing. It establishes a numerical surface finish specification and provides weld inspection and acceptance criteria, establishing a complete verification documentation chain, from material certifications to final reports. As a result of the level of detail required to verify documentation for ASME BPE lines, they are generally more expensive than 3-A lines due to the fact that all joints must be completed with documented production information and inspected welds.

Standard Region Approach What the certificate covers Relative cost
3-A United States prescriptive design criteria a specific numbered equipment design moderate
EHEDG Europe guidelines plus certification hygienic design principles of a component moderate
ASME BPE global, pharmaceutical numeric finish and weld criteria the documented build, joint by joint highest
None — supplier declaration only nothing verifiable lowest

The last row of the table illustrates where most buyers fall. A buyer has no way to verify the cleanability of a fitting if the seller lacks a certification. A buyer has the burden of proof regarding cleanability in a regulated environment, whereas the seller does not have that same burden.

The certificate that is relevant in a tender is the one that identifies the number on the certificate for the item. That is the common mistake made with sanitary procurement documents. If you have a 3-A certificate for a valve and quote that same certificate for a fitting, that is not covered by that certificate. The way that a 3-A certificate is written and what that certificate covers and does not cover can be seen in the example of 3-A 33-03 certification.

Where the cost difference comes from

The cost of a sanitary fitting is two to four times greater than an ordinary fitting of the same size and material, but not all that difference comes from the steel.

One of the first reasons is the material: 316L material will cost more than 304 material, and the mill price difference at the time of purchase is usually between 15 and 30 percent depending on the amounts of molybdenum and nickel.

The manufacturing process is the second and larger reason. A sanitary fitting is either forged or machined as opposed to cast, an internal radius is formed instead of left sharp, and the surface of the sanitary fitting is polished to a specified finish and inspected. This involves more operations per part with greater manual effort.

The documentation and certification is the third reason. For a buyer, having 3-A certification can be important as it establishes a connection between the tubes and their specifications as it relates to manufactured products and also allows the buyer to provide evidence of compliance to the regulatory authorities.

However, many buyers forget about the additional costs associated with gaskets and clamps when budgeting for fittings, especially when it involves multiple clamp joints (e.g., a line with 200 clamp joints would require 200 clamps and 200 gaskets). Gaskets are consumables and will need to be replaced at each scheduled inspection.

Frequently asked questions

Does sanitary mean sterile?

The term sanitary refers to being cleanable to a level, whereas sterile means having no viable microorganisms. A sanitary line may be cleaned and then subsequently sterilized; however, the sanitary design does not inherently sterilize anything. These steps are separate processes.

Can I use ordinary stainless fittings in a sanitary line?

While technically the line will maintain its structural integrity under pressure, it will not be cleanable to a defined standard. Any threaded connections in the product path hold product in the threads—the roots of the threads. Flushing will not remove the trapped product. Therefore, all fittings in the product line must be sanitary. Regular stainless steel fittings may be appropriate on utility lines (i.e., water lines) that do not carry products.

What is the difference between 304 and 316L for sanitary use?

316L contains molybdenum (2.0–3.0%), which helps to resist pitting due to chlorine exposure. Additionally, because of its lower carbon content than 304, 316L will not have carbide precipitation at welded joints when using a 316L pipe when exposed to dairy and chlorinated cleaning cycles over time. However, a 304 stainless steel pipe will produce pitting and thus create potential crevices that will not be cleanable.

What surface finish is required for sanitary tubing?

Ra ≤0.8 µm is the standard food-grade requirement, and for the biotechnology, pharmaceutical industries, Ra ≤0.38 µm is the standard. Both numbers will be taken at the product-contact surfaces of sanitary tubing, not external polished surfaces.

Are tri-clamp and SMS fittings interchangeable?

No. Tri-clamp fittings and SMS fittings both have different ferrules and gaskets. As such, they do not seal against each other. Therefore, if a line uses both tri-clamp and SMS fittings, there must be an adapter at every transition. This would create a crevice and therefore violate the sanitary nature of the fittings and the products being used.

References

Conclusion

Sanitary describes the function of a fitting and not how it looks. A fitting is considered sanitary when it can be cleaned to a defined standard. To achieve this, sanitary fittings must have a corrosion-resistant surface, no dead legs in their geometry, and a joint that can either seal without the use of a threaded product-contact joint or can be easily disassembled for inspection.

A buyer can determine if all sanitary fitting specifications are met by asking three questions: What is the surface roughness? Where can product collect? What certificate covers this item? If a supplier answers all three questions, the supplier is a source of sanitary fittings. If they only provide an image of a polished surface, then the supplier is selling non-sanitary fittings.

Kontaktformular